- promoting a clearer understanding of men's experience -


MENZ.org.nz Logo First visit to MENZ.org.nz? Here's our introduction page.
MENZ ISSUES

MENZ Issues: news and discussion about New Zealand men, fathers, family law, divorce, courts, protests, gender politics, and male health.

Wed 7th May 2014

Just go elsewhere is the answer …. ?

Filed under: Gender Politics,General — golfa @ 3:56 pm

A suggestion to have women-only swimming sessions in Hamilton has caused plenty of waves, with some people saying there should be male-only sessions as well.

Hamilton City Council’s manager for recreational swimming, Mathew Baylis says the proposal is not do to with segregation, but more to do with making women feel more comfortable being in the pool.

He says if the proposal goes ahead, they would only be looking at 90 minute sessions only once to twice a week.

Mr Baylis says there are other pools that men can use.

16 Responses to “Just go elsewhere is the answer …. ?”

  1. Alastair says:

    There may well be a valid reason for Female only sessions. However for every one It could be reversed and be reversed to Justify Male only Sessions. And what about exclusive sessions for those who have had gender reassignment surgery? The Mind Boggles!

  2. Downunder says:

    If it is a public pool then it should be open to the public at all times. I can accept part of the pool being used for a specific purpose but I don’t accept that men should have to be excluded at specific times for women only access.

    A man shouldn’t need to check the pool schedule in advance to see if he is allowed in.

    I can accept segregation as a matter of age. It wouldn’t bother me if there was a pensioners only pool – they deserve a bit of piece and quiet in their twilight years, especially if they need a caregiver in the pool.

    This special rights for women in New Zealand needs to stop.

  3. MurrayBacon says:

    Let them eat clonazepam (anti-anxiety drug).

    Then they can enjoy the pool along with everyone else, as a larger and more relaxed social group. Running very empty sessions is highly uneconomic and unnecessarily excludes other people who may be keen to use the pool.

  4. Lukenz says:

    A longer version of this article is on stuff.

    http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/10004301/Man-ban-at-public-pool

    You know when you get a little older, more experienced and see the types of boobs who make it into local councils just to have a go to get what no one else wants. They dish up such crap and think of ways to sell it to the public.

    Councillors – before you vote – Read and understand the law.

    Section 21(1a) of the Humans Rights Act 1993

    For the purposes of this Act, the prohibited grounds of discrimination are—
    (a) sex
    http://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/1993/0082/latest/DLM304475.html?search=sw_096be8ed80b74003_sex_25_se&p=1&sr=0

    Section 65 of the Humans Rights Act 1993 is very clear when you can exclude someone.

    Where any conduct, practice, requirement, or condition that is not apparently in contravention of any provision of this Part has the effect of treating a person or group of persons differently on 1 of the prohibited grounds of discrimination in a situation where such treatment would be unlawful under any provision of this Part other than this section, that conduct, practice, condition, or requirement shall be unlawful under that provision unless the person whose conduct or practice is in issue, or who imposes the condition or requirement, establishes good reason for it.

    I read this as it is unlawful to have a man ban unless the person whose conduct is an issue. And woman who are apprehensive about their bodies (another way of saying I’m too fat for men to look at me) does not pass the exceptions set down in the act.

    According to the Human Rights Commission there are some gender exceptions here.

    http://www.hrc.co.nz/enquiries-and-complaints-guide/what-can-i-complain-about/sex/

    Again, none of the exceptions on their site regarding gender allows for any discrimination against men in public funded swimming pools on the grounds of a small minority of brain damaged woman who are apprehensive about their bodies or woman who further want to breakdown the family unit.

  5. Shinhee Yi says:

    This jusr is outrageous how is it in nz it’s normal for women to discriminate againt man with some lunely excuss but with women are discriminated it’s unexceptable in all ground no excuse. There are many bixxxs only gym but are there male only gym around nz? I bet there aren’t any. I for one have personal example. I am training at mixed martial art gym at glenfield every monday and Wednesday there are womens only class before mainstream mma class. During the session no man can enter the gym. All man have to stay out till this bxtxhs class finish. This is ok during summer but in winter it just too harsh for us guys we have to stay out in rain socking wet waiting for our class to start. But the thing is almost every pro fighters contributing to this gym are the guys and not one are girl. There are less then ten girls in our gym and this girl are that good looking eather so no guy will bother them during their training even if they where these guys are good gentle guy who have no interest of doing such offensive thing to any of this girl. Way do man rights have to be undermind to make this girl fill comfortable this is bs.

  6. Man X Norton says:

    We demand white-skin-only sessions (those darker skinned people make white folk uncomfortable). And South-East Albanian only sessions, and sessions only for 43 year olds (all other ages make them uncomfortable). And sessions exclusively for jazz buffs; we’re really, really uncomfortable having to share swimming pool resources with pop and rap fans.

  7. Man X Norton says:

    Actually, the answer is not “just go elsewhere”. The pools are funded by all and discrimination needs to be challenged. A better answer is for several men, or even one man, to use the ‘woman’s pool’ regardless. Let them call police to come and arrest the male swimmer and make sure journalists are present for the melee.

  8. golfa says:

    #8. My mistake. I was so infuriated by the Council’s flippant solution that I forgot to add a question mark. I’ve fixed it now.

  9. Soothsayer says:

    Just go elsewhere. I tried living a quiet, honest life elsewhere and three times now the psychos have pursued me to wreck their havoc.

    Personally, I have no difficulty with the ‘lady only’ pool sessions. Especially if balanced with ‘gentlemen only’ sessions. Then I’m not at ground zero.

  10. Ministry of Men's Affairs says:

    FYI, our letter to Hamilton City Council (info@hcc.govt.nz), copies to:
    Human Rights Commission (infoline@hrc.co.nz)
    Ministry of Women’s Affairs (mwa@mwa.govt.nz)
    Jo Goodhew, Minister of Women’s Affairs (j.goodhew@ministers.govt.nz)
    Hon Judith Collins, Minister of Ethnic Affairs (j.collins@ministers.govt.nz)
    Hon Paula Bennett, Minister for Social Development (p.bennett@ministers.govt.nz)
    Hon Dr Pita Sharples, Minister of Maori Affairs (p.sharples@ministers.govt.nz)
    Hon Peseta Sam Lotu-Iiga, Minister of Pacific Island Affairs (peseta.sam.lotu-iiga@parliament.govt.nz)

    Contact email addresses are provided in case anyone else wants to make contact with them.

    If you wish to volunteer to join us when we visit the Hamilton Pool for a swim at the appropriate women’s only time, please contact Kerry Bevin, ph (09)4247762 or email mmainnz@gmail.com

    To Mathew Baylis, Manager for Recreational Swimming, Hamilton City Council

    Dear Mr Baylis

    We are aware that you are planning at council-owned pools to offer women-only pools for periods of time on the basis that will make the women more comfortable.

    Can you inform us about the session times for white-skin-only pool sessions? We believe that some white-skinned people would feel more comfortable not having to share a pool with darker-skinned people. There is a good basis for the discomfort of those white-skinned people because crime statistics show that Maori and Polynesians commit higher rates of violent and sexually violent crime.

    Actually, we don’t approve of discrimination on the basis of gender or race, but if your council insists on practising discrimination then there will be many other groups who might demand similar privilege.

    If your council proceeds with women-only pool sessions in the absence of similar privileges for other groups including men, we plan to send groups of men to swim peacefully in the women’s only pool. We will welcome any aggressive security or police action that you may choose to elicit against our representatives; media personnel will be present to record this.

    Kind regards

    Kerry Bevin
    Manager
    Ministry of Men’s Affairs (A community group because successive NZ governments have ignored the voice, rights and welfare of men)

  11. Daniel says:

    The only problem with men only sessions is that they would likely be attended by the type of men who make red blooded fellers like us feel uncomfortable – then that would be TWO sessions we couldn’t attend.

  12. Had_Enough says:

    May I suggest Burkini’s for all and while we’re at it can we please adopt Sharia law for all also. Perhaps that will allow men to have a say in NZ society again and allow them a role in the upbringing of their children.

  13. FeministHater says:

    I just hate the fact that discirminating against man is widely accepted in New Zealand.

    Hunmen rights law on discrimination doesn’t include man?

    I think this unfairness between the gander cause conflict and leads to D.V out of frustration and hate.

    some woman deserve [suggestion inconsistent with the rules removed by moderator].

  14. OMG You're (&*)^*( says:

    Maybe we could have ‘girl-only’ clubs such as Girl’s Brigade, Girl Guides? Oh wait. We have that already.
    Maybe we could have ‘boy-only’ clubs such as Boy Scouts? Oh wait. We had to open that up to girls.

    Maybe we could have women-only clubs such as gyms? Oh wait. We have that already.
    Maybe we could have men-only clubs such as the Auckland Workingmen’s club? Oh wait. We had to open that up to women.

    Maybe we could have men-only sports such as At. Andrew’s Golf Club? Oh wait – that’s about to open up to women …

  15. Click says:

    I do think that is certainly among the most essential information and facts in my opinion. And i am fulfilled researching your write-up. Yet choose to observation about quite a few basic challenges, The positioning flavour is great, a content articles was in reason for point good : Deborah. Good approach, all the best

Leave a Reply

Connect with Facebook

Please note that comments which do not conform with the rules of this site are now likely to be removed. They should be on-topic for the page they are on. Discussions about moderation are specifically forbidden.

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

« »

Powered by WordPress