In 2005 airlines such as Air New Zealand and Qantas were found to have a policy that children and teenagers who are unaccompanied by parents or caregivers cannot sit next to men. Air New Zealand spokesman David Jamieson said the company had no intention of reviewing the policy and admitted that it had been in place for many years.British Airways also has the same policy which was revealed in 2001.
Ex Feminist leader of the Children’s Commissioner Cindy Kiro stated “children’s safety is paramount and she commends the airline for putting thought into how it can keep children safe.” Interestingly, her feminist ideology states that men cannot be trusted with children and they should not be encouraged to have a position of trust around children.
In return a number of men spoke up against the policy including politicians.
Michael Irwin, a former school principal and now senior lecturer at Massey University’s College of Education, says the policy adopted by Air New Zealand and Qantas sent a “misleading message” that men were uncaring when it came to young children.
“It’s saying to society that it’s not men’s role to be involved with their children or any children and that’s ridiculous,” he said.
Mr Irwin said such policies could cause men to feel alienated from schools, childcare centres and nursing, and were also harmful to the wider society, which would miss out on male involvement.
“If a child falls down and hurts themselves. . . is a man supposed to stand around until a woman can be found to help?
“I believe it sends a signal to children: ‘don’t trust a man’.”
The director of the Centre for Public Policy at Massey University, Stuart Birks, said the ban was “a clear case of discrimination with no obvious rational basis”.
It was as “pointless and ridiculous” as discriminating against passengers on grounds of race, religious belief, or appearance, he said.
“Would they have a policy of not seating children next to Maori passengers, or skinheads or Muslims? or only male Maori, skinheads and Muslims?”
The story also featured on TV One Close Up. Susan Wood read out part of an e-mail by MRA Darryl Ward:
(more…)