MENZ Issues: news and discussion about New Zealand men, fathers, family law, divorce, courts, protests, gender politics, and male health.

Call for DNA testing at birth

Filed under: Child Support,Law & Courts — JohnPotter @ 9:54 am Thu 9th June 2005

A pro-fathers’ group wants to see DNA testing at birth to help men who are paying for children that are not theirs.

The suggestion comes as the Ministry of Social Development is reportedly having to pay $10,000 to a Christchurch man who was forced to pay for another man’s child.

Spokesman for the Union of Fathers Darrell Carlin says Mr Dowler is not the only one, and instituting a system where DNA testing is carried out at birth would solve the problem.

Lobby group wants free paternity tests

“Devastated” men are battling to prove they are not the biological fathers of children they are forced to support, says a group seeking changes to the child support system.

James Nicolle, a spokesman for the group Parents for Children, said his organisation was dealing with four other men in the same situation as a Christchurch man who has just won a 21-year battle to be repaid child support payments for another man’s child.

Mr Nicolle said the Inland Revenue Department would not accept the results of a paternity test unless they had written approval from a child’s mother.

Mr Nicolle told NZPA the men being helped by his group were devastated and saw “no way out”.

In one case he could only talk to the man’s partner, because the man became so upset when he discussed the problem that he could not sleep.

Parents for Children wanted a system that provided “fair and reasonable” child support, and for changes to the laws involving the way separated parents were able to parent and support their children.

The amount taken by the IRD depended on a person’s income, with one of the men he was working with at the higher end paying $1200 a month.

Mr Nicolle said children and parents had a right to know if a man was a child’s father.

“If they aren’t the father an awful lot of damage can be done for both sides. It’s a terrible thing to have to face.”

It was not just about money, with many other issues related to paternity. A person’s genetic heritage had cultural and health implications, he said.

Parents for Children would like to see free DNA testing for any father who chose to have it done, without a child’s mother being able to act as a “gate keeper”.


  1. I totally agree to this common sense approach. Well done Jim and the team – just maybe we are finally getting heard – now wouldn’t that be a big turnaround??

    Comment by Peter Burns — Thu 9th June 2005 @ 10:23 am

  2. The first step on the road. Perhaps now, the politicians may start to listen to the message that “child support” and “family law” in New Zealand fail children and parents.

    Well done, Jim and Parents for Children!

    Comment by Ethos — Thu 9th June 2005 @ 11:11 am

  3. A good thing to push for. Goodonya Jim and Co.
    Of course the male pill will mean that men will have much more control over which when they fertilise a female.

    Comment by Stephen — Thu 9th June 2005 @ 12:13 pm

  4. A disturbing factor in such cases is the refusal by mothers to grant permission for these tests. It stands to reason that that such women know full-well the likely outcome of such tests. To knowingly commit a man to raising another’s child without his consent is a henious action that IMO warrants the severest of penalties.

    Comment by Richard — Sat 6th August 2005 @ 12:15 am

  5. I think this is a great idea and will stop all the confusion and problems we currently have. Money aside, I know that I would like to know who my father was, even if he was a criminal in jail. What right does another person (mother) have to affect someones life in this way?!

    Comment by Daryl Leaf — Tue 20th September 2005 @ 6:45 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

Please note that comments which do not conform with the rules of this site are likely to be removed. They should be on-topic for the page they are on. Discussions about moderation are specifically forbidden. All spam will be deleted within a few hours and blacklisted on the stopforumspam database.

This site is cached. Comments will not appear immediately unless you are logged in. Please do not make multiple attempts.

Skip to toolbar