MENZ Issues: news and discussion about New Zealand men, fathers, family law, divorce, courts, protests, gender politics, and male health.

A blow for White ribbon

Filed under: General — JohnBrett @ 3:03 pm Sun 7th June 2009

I wrote to following letter, to Min of justice, and a few politicians.
Responses below:
1 Letter

Subject: Offensive material displayed in North Shore District Court

I am objecting to a poster for the “White Ribbon” campaign, displayed in the office of the North Shore Family Court.

The “White ribbon” campaign has the laudable aim of opposing violence against women, but is not concerned about violence against men, nor violence against children. In addition, men are depicted as the sole perpetrators of domestic violence.

For these reasons the “White Ribbon” Campaign is at best a factional interest group, and could be seen as promulgating “hate speech”. Allowing such groups to promote their extremist dogma actually exacerbates the problem of domestic violence by excusing the violence suffered by children and their fathers, at the hands of the many violent women, and promoting the removal of fathers from their families.

You will of course be aware that domestic violence has been shown by all reputable studies committed equally by men and women, and that most violence against children is committed by women. You will of course be aware that violence to children is 50 to 70 TIMES higher in fatherless homes.

Allowing these offensive posters to be displayed in Family Court offices is distressing and offensive to male victims of domestic violence, and to their children who may have suffered abuse at the hands of a woman. These posters reinforce the perception that the Family Court has an anti-father, and an antifamily bias.

All Family Courts should be instructed to remove these offensive posters immediately.

Yours sincerely

John Brett

2 Response 1



Tahu o te Ture

4 June 2009

John Brett
PO Box 100061
North Shore Mail Centre

Tena koe John Brett


Thank you for your letter of 7 May 2009 regarding a poster for the White Ribbon campaign being displayed in the North Shore Family Court.

Due to the need for the court system to be, and to be seen to be impartial, Ministry staff were specifically instructed that White Ribbon day should not be promoted in Courts. Ministry staff may wear a White Ribbon as a personal statement of support if they choose.

1 have reiterated this position to the Court manager at the North Shore Family Court and am assured that all posters promoting White Ribbon day have now been removed. 1 thank you for bringing this matter to my attention and apologise for any distress this may have caused.


Tony Fisher
V General Manager, District Courts

PO Box 180, Wellington, New Zealand
Telephone: +64 4 918 8800 Fax: +64 4 918 8820

2 Response 2

Office of Hon Paula Bennett

MP for Waitakere
Minister for Social Development and Employment
Minister for Disability Issues
Minister of Youth Affairs

2 9 MAY 2099

John Brett
John Brett Technology Ltd
P 0 Box 10 0061 NSIVIC

Dear Mr Brett

Thank you for your letter of 8 May 2009 about the White Ribbon Campaign.

I read your letter with interest. I can assure you that the Government’s responses to family violence prevention are aimed at all members of our society women, men and children in New Zealand.

However, statistics indicate that most family violence in New Zealand is directed towards women and children.

The White Ribbon Day is an international day when people wear a white ribbon to show that they do not condone violence towards women. 1 applaud any initiative that raises the profile of family violence and sends a message that it is not ok.

Thank you for writing.

Yours sincerely

Hon Paula Bennet) Minister for Social Development and Employment

Private Bag 18041, Parliament Buildings, Wellington 6160, New Zealand. Telephone 64 4 817 6815 Facsimile 64 4 817 6515

John Brett

9 Responses to “A blow for White ribbon”

  1. Skeptik says:

    So that’s all you got from the ‘honorable’ Paula Bennett?
    Just thanks but everything is swell?
    Holy shit!
    Talk about callous indifference towards the suffering of men!

  2. Alastair says:

    I believe heaps of letters to the minister. I would have thought that she would have taken a more dispassionate view.

  3. Jim Bailey says:

    Good letter John-B and one good responce – I hope you write back to Paula-B and ask her were she got her info – I have sent her heaps of stuff about the issue from David Fergusson, Stuart Birks, Paul Calister and Felicity I think and others – Let alone some of my personal experiences – Same wishy-Washy responce so far anyway – Onward – Jim

  4. John (A different one :) says:

    Great piece John. And the reply from the family court is quite encouraging.
    I do have one question; the facts that you mentioned are very interesting
    as I’ve heard various statistics (lies, lies and then there’s statistics..).
    Do you have references to those figures ?
    I’m thinking about writing a handbook on the family court; the what, whys and the hows. I want the innocent Joe (or Jane) to be aware of ALL of the scams that occur behind those closed doors and arm them with facts and information.
    If I get it published I’ll make sure that government bodies such as MSD receive a complimentary copy as it sounds as if they need educating.

  5. John (A different one :) says:

    Re-reading the reply from Paula Bennett I decided to do a quick bit of research on the white ribbon.. very interesting indeed.
    Now I agree that wikipedia is definitive place for answsers but it’s got me interested enough to follow this up with some deeper digging around now. Take a look for yourself…

  6. julie says:

    Good on you Jim. Great stuff.

  7. julie says:

    Great stuff John. Thank-you for sharing the responses.

  8. Dave says:

    Well done John!! That is excellent work!!
    Thanks also to Jim.
    Obviously some re-education for Paula Bennett is imperative.

  9. Dave says:

    Oh – just read about white ribbon being symbol of feminist movement. That is very useful indeed. News headline: NZ Family court covers walls with feminist symbols!

Leave a Reply

Please note that comments which do not conform with the rules of this site are likely to be removed. They should be on-topic for the page they are on. Discussions about moderation are specifically forbidden. All spam will be deleted within a few hours and blacklisted on the stopforumspam database.

This site is cached. Comments will not appear immediately unless you are logged in. Please do not make multiple attempts.

Skip to toolbar